Alberta Business Alliance Thought Leader Insight
|

An EU “partnership” or “Alliance for the Future” is not the answer to dealing with the U.S.

France is a symptom of what is wrong with Europe: paralysis and polarization. Its electorate is shifting to the nationalist right and Marxist-leaning left, neither of which has answers for France’s fiscal, social and security issues. Trying to balance the country’s budget by cutting far-too-generous pensions and social handouts might well spark a revolution. Nor is growth an answer: the country’s competitiveness has been hampered by over-regulation, high taxes and an education system that’s underfunded because of costly teacher pensions.

The EU is an economic not a political union. Its treaty guarantees freedom of movement of goods, services, capital and people among member countries. It has achieved monetary integration via its own currency, the Euro, although not all members have adopted it. In its early days the EU prospered but it has since experienced low economic growth and a standard of living that is falling behind the United States.

Paralysis in decision-making, high taxes, and over 15,000 EU regulations have undermined European productivity, not just France’s. The EU’s share of world GDP (adjusted for purchasing power parity) has declined from 27 per cent in 1980 to 14 per cent today. In contrast, the United States share has remained at roughly 26 per cent though it has fluctuated over the years.

Given this backdrop, why is Canada seeking deeper economic and security ties with an underperforming European Union? This week’s Canada-EU summit in Montreal has already been downgraded from a discussion about “partnership” to one regarding an “alliance for the future” — this due to Germans’ and others’ opposition to special membership for Canada. For now, this suits Canada, which is only looking for new agreements in trade, defence, education and research to help reduce its dependence on the U.S.

This is not the first time Canada has tried to do that, of course. In 1971, U.S. president Richard Nixon imposed a 10-per cent surcharge on imports to help stabilize the value of the U.S. dollar. Canada responded by pursuing the “Third Option” of a contractual link to the European Economic Community (EEC). But geography, economics and security concerns eventually overwhelmed the push to diversify trade. By 1988, anti-Americanism took a back seat and Canada signed the Canada-U.S. free trade agreement, later expanded to NAFTA to include Mexico.

Canada is and will remain critical to U.S. security no matter who is president so any attempts to go beyond improving trade with Europe and reach new political arrangements like “associate membership” will raise concerns in Washington. Even after Trump and Carney are long gone politically, the U.S. still won’t want Canada leaving its security orbit. Nor should Canada want to give up access to the largest, most dynamic market in the world.

Author’s update — October 30, 2026: After I wrote this article, the President of the EU Commission doubled down yesterday calling the Canada-EU relationship an “associate partnership”. This position is surprising since several key member states, who have the ultimate authority, are in opposition to the term: the official tag even on Canada’s website is an “alliance for the future”. Seems expectations differ even without knowing what the commitments will be.

A version of this article also appears in the Financial Post.

Author

  • Jack M. Mintz

    Dr. Jack M. Mintz is President’s Fellow at the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary and its founding Director. A widely published economist and public policy expert, his work focuses on taxation, economic growth, investment and fiscal policy.

Similar Posts